Which Mattress Toppers Are Best?

A layer of cushioning can make your bed more comfortable. It may help relieve pressure on joints. But which mattress covers are the best?

Dr. Holliday-Bell recommends this natural option for those who need the conforming support of memory foam but wish to stay clear of chemical. It comes with an easy-to-clean cover and the firmness options allow most sleepers to find their comfort.

1. Sleep Innovations Gel Memory Topper

The topper is soft and comfortable for most people, but still provides support. It moulded to the shape of our testers' bodies and offered support in all the right places. It is suitable for all mattresses, but it can be a bit difficult to place the sheets on. (Read more about how to put in mattress toppers here). Its thick layer of memory foam is machine washable and naturally antibacterial. It has an organic bamboo cover that is non-toxic and sustainably sourced. It was a favorite among our panelists, however it's important to note that it doesn't have any straps to help anchor the top of your bed and it's possible that it will move while you sleep.

The panelists who loved this topper also loved the way it eased back pain. It's a great choice for sleepers with heavier weights who might discover that a topper with a depth of three to four inches can ease pressure on a sensitive area like shoulders and hips.

A two-inch layer of copper-infused memory foam wicks heat and promotes airflow to ensure a cool night's sleep. The topper was firm enough to ease her back pain as well as the front and side sleeping positions, but not too rigid that it made her feel uncomfortable. She also noticed that the back pain "pretty quickly disappeared overnight." She was also impressed by the quietness of the topper, even when paired with a spring mattress. The topper is also great for couples who share beds as it stops motion transfer.

2. Coop Home Goods Retreat

We love the plush pillow feel of Coop Home Goods' caravan mattress topper toppers and this spot-cleaning-only version came up in our research we knew it was a must to be included. It's made with an intercut memory foam and microfiber blend that is made by the company, making it hypoallergenic. This is ideal for anyone looking to upgrade a soft mattress, or even re-decorate a bed in the guest room, dorm or rented. What makes this topper especially unique is the inclusion of five body-zones with different density zones, which helps to shape and conform to your body's unique shape and still provide sufficient support.

The cover of this mattress protector is made from 100-percent microfiber poly that has been brushed. It features a baffle box design that creates pockets that evenly distribute the fill. It also has four elastic straps at each corner to keep the cover securely on your mattress. A layer of copper-infused memory foam draws heat away from your body to keep you cool at night, and it's topped with a 2" layer of memory foam mattress topper double foam that is ventilated for even more breathability.

The Retreat is an excellent mattress topper if you want a plush feeling. Louise is a Strategist writer, stated that when she tried it out the topper quickly adjusted and cradled so that she felt comfortable and well-supported. She is prone to overheating in bed but the Retreat managed to keep her cool and didn't shift much during the night. It's available in two different firmness options, and back, side, and stomach sleepers will find it to be a good fit for their preferences.

3. Nolah Beds Luxury Firm Memory Foam Topper

If you're looking for a mattress cover there are a lot of options available. Some are designed to keep your body cool or regulate body temperature, while others provide some additional support or comfort. A mattress topper is an excellent way to improve your current bed without spending much money. A memory foam mattress is a great choice for the majority of people. However, if you prefer a more springy innerspring mattress topper double bed then a hybrid topper combining nano-springs and latex may be a better choice.

For side and back sleepers, a more firm topper can better align your spine and reduce pressure on the sensitive areas. This 4-inch Tempur topper, manufactured in the US, has 120 nights of trial and has was a huge hit with our tester Julia. She was able to sleep better and was happy with the extra comfort it gave her old mattress. She did notice a strong off-gassing smell when she opened it, but that dissipated after a few days.

This firm option from Parachute offers shredded memory foam that's not as dense but still feels comfortable. Lauren Levy, a Strategist contributor, says it's "much cheaper than a down topper" and has the same marshmallow softness. She loved sleeping on it, but doesn't recommend it for front sleepers due to her torso cratered in the top.

A topper made from natural wool fleece is hypoallergenic and soft. It's not as breathable, and can make you feel hot at night. Cotton is a good option, as it is air-conditioned and keeps you cool. Certain fabrics are infused with graphite or copper to keep you cool.

4. Sleep Innovations Gel Cooling Memory Foam Topper

This topper from Puffy is an excellent budget choice, offering a soft feeling and gentle pressure-relieving assistance at a affordable cost. It also comes with a range of density and thickness options, making it simple to find the right mattress for you.

Lauren Levy, a Strategist contributor, loved the fact that this topper is "marshmallow-soft" and has a baffle box construction with pillows-like fiber-fill. Plus, it's hypoallergenic, and comes with a machine-washable cover to ensure the hygiene of your bed.

The topper's 2" layer of copper-infused memory foam encourages airflow and wicks moisture during sleep, allowing you to stay cool. Levy found that it was extremely comfortable, even when it didn't bounce nearly as much as latex toppers. It's great for side, back or stomach sleepers, as well as those with chronic pain who need extra cushioning.

A 10-year warranty as well as free shipping come standard. This topper can be cleaned easily by spot-cleaning it and letting it air dry. Be careful not to put it in the washer or dryer because it will invalidate the warranty.

The Sleep Innovations Gel Cooling Memory Foam Topper offers a great budget option for a dependable soft mattress. It offers moderate (5) firmness which makes it ideal for most sleepers, but more so for those who feel their mattresses are too firm. It also prevents movement transfer, which is essential for sleepers who are combination. It also relieves shoulder and neck pain, like the Coop Home Goods Retreat topper. The only drawback of this topper is that it might not be as breathable as latex or polyfoam, so it's not the ideal choice for mattress topper double thick those who sleep hot.

5. Nolah Beds Luxury Plush Memory Foam Topper

The Nolah Beds Luxury Plush Memory Foam Topper is an excellent choice for back sleepers looking to soften their mattress as well as for side sleepers who want extra cushioning. This topper also helps reduce pressure points, making it a good choice for those with chronic pain. It's made in the USA with non-toxic materials and is a good choice for those who sleep hot. It has a 2" layer of copper-infused foam that promotes breathability as well as providing support. It has a cover made of organic cotton which helps to manage the moisture. Our test subject Paige found that this mattress did a good job of stopping motion transfer and providing significant softness without sacrificing support. However, she noticed that the edges did not fully cover her Mattress topper double thick and if support for edges is important for you, this may not be the right topper for you.

This topper is also simple to clean since it comes with a removable and washable cover. In addition, it's hypoallergenic as well as antibacterial to ensure a healthy night's sleep. It's also made with five body zones to support various areas of the mattress. It also comes with a warranty and a sleep trial of 120 nights which is more than competitors' policies.

This is among the cheaper alternatives in our list but it's not skimping on quality. It's constructed with a mix of memory foam and latex that provides an extremely soft feel to any 2ft 6 mattress topper. It's a more dense layer of memory foam to provide more comfort and encourage a restful sleep. While it may not be the ideal choice for stomach sleepers because it tends to sink too much and could cause misalignment of the spine It's a great option for those looking to get a better night's sleep for less.